Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Recent Reviews Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › Cincinnati › New York

Pizza review

Goodfellas Pizzeria

Cincinnati · OTR · New York · Feb 2022

Goodfellas Pizzeria

a cartoonishly oversized (two plate) New York slice, with the chewy foldable crust you look for in that style

Keep browsing

City guideMore in Cincinnati Style guideMore New York Same cityWayfarer Same styleAndrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria

7.4Worth the Calories

City: Cincinnati
Neighborhood: OTR
Style: New York
Date: Feb 2022
Address: 1211 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45202

Map All reviews

The Slice Index · 333 pizzerias · 30 cities · Last updated June 2026